Kim Kardashian is no stranger to public scrutiny, but this time, she’s taken a more humorous approach to handling the negative reviews of her new Hulu legal drama, All’s Fair. Despite the scathing reviews from critics, Kardashian remains unfazed, sharing a playful Instagram post that pokes fun at the mixed reactions. The show, created by Ryan Murphy, has garnered both praise and harsh criticism, with Kardashian’s lighthearted response showing she’s not taking the negativity too seriously.
Let’s break down the response to All’s Fair, the show’s premise, its star-studded cast, and how the public is reacting to this new project.
All’s Fair: What You Need to Know
All’s Fair is a legal drama that follows the story of Allura Grant (played by Kim Kardashian), a successful divorce lawyer who opens an all-female law firm in Los Angeles. The show tackles the challenges she faces in the cutthroat legal world, balancing her career with her personal life. Alongside Kardashian, the cast includes Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Matthew Noszka, Sarah Paulson, Glenn Close, Judith Light, Ed O’Neill, and O-T Fagbenle.
The series is produced by Ryan Murphy, who is known for his work on American Horror Story, Glee, and The Politician. This marks Kardashian’s second collaboration with Murphy, following her role in American Horror Story: Delicate.
Cast and Crew: The Talent Behind All’s Fair
While All’s Fair has had a mixed reception, the talent behind the show is undeniable. Along with Kim Kardashian, the series features a stellar cast, including some of the biggest names in Hollywood.
| Actor | Role | Notable Works |
|---|---|---|
| Kim Kardashian | Allura Grant | Keeping Up with the Kardashians, American Horror Story: Delicate |
| Naomi Watts | TBA | 21 Grams, The Impossible |
| Niecy Nash-Betts | TBA | When They See Us, Reno 911! |
| Sarah Paulson | TBA | American Horror Story, The People v. O.J. Simpson |
| Glenn Close | TBA | Fatal Attraction, The Wife |
The Reviews: A Mixed Response
Despite its high-profile cast, All’s Fair has received largely negative reviews from critics. The series premiered on November 4, 2025, and has struggled to impress with a near 0% score on Rotten Tomatoes. As of the latest update, the show holds a dismal 5% critical score, though it has a more favorable 67% audience rating.
Variety’s Alison Herman:
“All’s Fair is a clumsy, condescending take on rah-rah girlboss feminism, half-baked even by the standards of an overextended Murphy.
Kim Kardashian’s Response: Humor Over Haters
In a humorous twist, Kim Kardashian took to Instagram to share her reaction to the negative reviews. She posted a carousel of images, including sarcastic reviews, with a cheeky caption encouraging people to watch All’s Fair for the “most critically acclaimed show of the year!” The post included a range of comments, from genuine praise to more sarcastic critiques.
One of the reviews she shared from Twitter (now X) read:
“Some of the worst acting I’ve ever seen in my life alongside the most predictable storylines and the most ridiculous styling. I’m obsessed; I need 14 seasons.”
Kardashian’s playful tone in sharing the reviews proves that she’s not bothered by the criticism and is taking it all in stride. As she wrote in the caption, “Have you tuned in to the most critically acclaimed show of the year!?!?!?”
The Audience: Mixed Reactions
Despite the critical reviews, All’s Fair has gained some supporters on social media. A few fans have posted on X (formerly Twitter), defending the show and praising its entertainment value. One user even joked:
“Critics realizing their reviews of [‘All’s Fair’] ended up making people watch and love the show.”
Another fan wrote:
“All’s Fair on Hulu dares to ask the question ‘Does a show need to be good?’ and the answer is no, it doesn’t.”
While the reviews may not be favorable across the board, it seems that there is still a portion of the audience who finds enjoyment in the show’s over-the-top approach and bold performances.
Why It Matters?
All’s Fair marks Kim Kardashian’s return to scripted acting after her appearance in American Horror Story: Delicate. While her acting credits are relatively few, this show is an important step in her career as she moves beyond her reality TV persona. It’s clear that Kardashian is committed to expanding her horizons, and despite the critical feedback, she continues to push herself into new roles and genres.
The Times’ Ben Dowell:
“Well done, Kim. You must have quite a healthy ego yourself to star in what may well be the worst television drama ever made. It’s so bad, it’s not even enjoyably so.”
This is also significant for Ryan Murphy, who has a long track record of creating hit shows that blend drama, humor, and spectacle. All’s Fair follows in the footsteps of his other shows, even if it hasn’t resonated with critics in the same way as his previous works. The series serves as a platform for his unique storytelling style, with a focus on empowered women, feminism, and the legal world.
FAQs
All’s Fair is a legal drama that follows Allura Grant, a successful divorce lawyer, as she navigates her career and personal life while running an all-female law firm in Los Angeles.
Critics have criticized the show for its lackluster writing, over-the-top performances, and uneven tone. Some reviews describe it as a “clumsy” take on feminism, with a predictable storyline and poorly executed humor.
While Kardashian has received praise for her presence in the show, her acting has been criticized in some reviews, with one calling it “some of the worst acting I’ve ever seen.”
According to creator Ryan Murphy, the show was always intended to be a limited series, and there are no plans for a second season.
All’s Fair is available to stream on Hulu, with new episodes releasing weekly.
