The emotional rollercoaster of Nobody Wants This Season 2 has only just landed on Netflix, but speculation is already running high about a third season. With creator Erin Foster and star Kristen Bell teasing ongoing work in the writers’ room, signs are pointing toward an early renewal.
The romantic dramedy, which follows the unlikely love story between agnostic podcaster Joanne (Kristen Bell) and devout rabbi Noah (Adam Brody), has become one of Netflix’s most acclaimed originals of the past two years. Season 2 ended on a hopeful note—but also set the stage for deeper emotional and cultural conflicts in Season 3.
Official Renewal Status: Pending, But Writer’s Room Is Active
As of October 23, 2025, Netflix has not officially renewed Nobody Wants This for Season 3. However, strong indicators suggest a green light is imminent.
According to listings in the Writers Guild of America (WGA) directory, the show’s writers’ room has already opened for Season 3—a clear sign that creative development is underway.
Kristen Bell confirmed this in a recent Parade interview, stating:
“The writer’s room is working right now. You never know if you’re gonna be able to shoot because that’s way above our pay grade… But the writer’s room is writing it right now. That we know.”
Expert Commentary
Television analyst Mara Klein, speaking with TV Insider, noted:
“When Netflix opens a writers’ room before an official renewal, it’s usually a formality—they’re preparing for fast turnaround. Given Season 2’s early success metrics, a Season 3 renewal seems almost guaranteed.”
Critical Reception and Performance
Season 2 currently boasts a 90% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with audiences praising its heartfelt balance of humor and faith-based storytelling.
According to entertainment journalist Rafael Gomez,
“The chemistry between Bell and Brody is the show’s heartbeat. Viewers are drawn to the emotional authenticity—it’s rare for romantic comedies to explore religion and relationships with such nuance.”
Given its performance trajectory, Nobody Wants This could easily become one of Netflix’s flagship romantic comedies heading into 2026.
What Season 3 Could Explore?
1. Joanne’s Conversion Journey
The second season’s finale hinted that Joanne may finally embrace Judaism—not as a requirement for Noah, but as an act of personal meaning. After a moving conversation with Esther, she began to recognize her quiet connection to Jewish culture.
Season 3 will likely explore her path toward conversion, potentially including comedic missteps and heartfelt reflections on belonging.
2. Noah’s Faith and Family Dynamics
Noah’s internal conflict between faith and love remains central to the narrative. His decision to prioritize Joanne over tradition creates ripple effects for his career and family life. Expect emotional tension with his mother, Bina Roklov, and further introspection about his rabbinical identity.
Cultural critic Eli Rosenfeld observes:
“Season 3 will likely depict Noah finding a new balance—where devotion to love doesn’t mean a rejection of faith.”
3. Possible Engagement
The finale’s reconciliatory kiss left fans buzzing about marriage speculation. With the couple back together and stronger than ever, an engagement seems inevitable by the end of Season 3. Adam Brody hinted in an interview with USA Today:
“There’s marriage, if they should want that… there’s children, if they should want that.”
4. Sasha and Esther’s Separation
The secondary storyline involving Sasha and Esther may dominate Season 3’s emotional subplots. While the pair appeared headed for divorce, viewers can expect jealousy, introspection, and—perhaps—a rekindled bond.
Meanwhile, Esther’s character could find herself navigating single life for the first time in years, providing both comedic and reflective moments.
5. Morgan and Sasha’s Friendship
The platonic chemistry between Morgan and Sasha remains one of the show’s standout relationships. While fans speculate about romantic undertones, insiders suggest that their connection will remain sibling-like. Maintaining that dynamic reinforces the show’s mature handling of adult relationships and boundaries.
Season 3 Release Window
The previous two seasons premiered as follows:
| Season | Release Date |
|---|---|
| Season 1 | September 26, 2024 |
| Season 2 | October 23, 2025 |
If Netflix follows its current annual cycle—and assuming production begins early in 2026—Season 3 could arrive by November 2026. However, this assumes no major scheduling conflicts or production delays.
Industry insider Dara Patel notes:
“Netflix’s comedy division tends to fast-track relationship-driven hits like Nobody Wants This. If the renewal is formalized by November, a 2026 premiere is highly realistic.”
Why Fans Relate to Nobody Wants This?
Beyond its romantic tension, the series resonates because it explores spiritual identity, modern love, and female autonomy with humor and heart. Erin Foster’s writing deftly examines cultural differences while keeping its tone witty and self-aware.
Entertainment psychologist Dr. Lena Moore adds:
“Viewers connect with Joanne because she embodies the conflict between independence and vulnerability. The show’s emotional realism is its secret weapon.”
Table: Current Cast and Expected Returns
| Actor | Character | Status in Season 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Kristen Bell | Joanne | Returning |
| Adam Brody | Noah | Returning |
| Justine Lupe | Morgan | Returning |
| Tovah Feldshuh | Bina Roklov | Returning |
| Paul Ben-Victor | Ilan Roklov | Returning |
| Jackie Tohn | Esther Roklov | Returning |
| Timothy Simons | Sasha Roklov | Returning |
| Leighton Meester | Abby | Expected |
| Miles Fowler | Lenny | Expected |
FAQs
Not yet officially, but the writers’ room has opened—making renewal highly likely.
If renewal comes by late 2025, fans can expect a release in late 2026, following the same production timeline as the previous seasons.
All signs point to yes—Season 2’s ending suggests her emotional and spiritual readiness to take that step.
It’s very likely. The couple reconciled at the end of Season 2, and both actors have hinted at the natural progression toward marriage.
There’s no official word, but creator Erin Foster has hinted at multi-season story arcs, meaning Season 3 may not be the final chapter.
